Tuesday, October 5, 2010

Review: The Gendarme

Author: Mark Mustian
Genre: Fiction (2010)

About: A 92-year-old Turkish man, now living in America, is diagnosed with a brain tumor.  He has vivid dreams about his time as a gendarme during the Armenian war when he escorted Armenian refugees to Syria in a death march. He falls in love with Araxie, a young Armenian girl, loses touch with her, and years later desperately tries to find her.

Gendarme (pronounced /dʒɛnˈdɑrm/ or /ˈʒɑːndɑrm/)
 Gendarme (historical), French medieval or early modern cavalryman

  • I found the writing to be choppy and stiff, and the tone, monotonous. I thought I'd adjust as I read further but that didn't happen. Until the last chapter. Which I enjoyed because the author finally gave the characters, Emmett Conn and his long lost love, Araxie, more emotional depth. Why did he wait so long to do that? To make for a climactic ending? 
  • The majority of the book was dull, probably because I didn't feel a connection to the main character and didn't really care what happened to him.
  • The alternating tense between his dream state and the present wasn't always clear. I wish these would have been chapter by chapter or at least more fluidly written. 
  • Emmett Conn's daughter Violet was mean and rude, especially the way she made decisions for her father - where he was going to live, who would "monitor" him.  I didn't like her.
  • Just as I was finally enjoying the last chapter, the only one I liked, it was over just like that...with a vague and boring ending.
Source: Library

Why I Chose: The cover is beautiful and I had seen it on a few blogs so I was curious.

Recommend? I don't want to say no, because a lot of people liked this book. I'd actually like you to read it if you've had it on your radar at all, and then let me know your thoughts. It's one of those you either love or feel indifferent towards.

Rating: 2.5 / 5  (Normally I wouldn't finish a book I rate this low. But I did because I wanted to be able to review it.)

Comments (11)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Sure doesn't seem wading through just for a few pages you liked.
My recent post Up On The Roof
1 reply · active 756 weeks ago
I know! I don't know why I kept plugging away. I guess I was semi-curious to see what happened in the end and whether or not he found Araxie.
This one seems to be one of those that you either love or hate. I'm still thinking about reading it but if I feel anything remotely like you did I'm sure I'll just toss it into the library dropbox!
My recent post September totals at a glance
1 reply · active 756 weeks ago
Staci, I want you to read it! But definitely if you're hating it after 25 or 50 pages (whatever your "rule" is...mine's 50) you should give it up. And that's one thing about the library - you don't feel bad about giving it up, whereas a bought book I'd feel obligated to finish.
Well, I did read a lot of reviews of this book, and in a way I'm curious because I want to see how it plays out. You know, it's like one of those books where the synopsis is interesting enough to make you want to read it. But I did read a few reviews where the readers took a while to get into it.
My recent post Review- The Game On! Diet by Krista Vernoff and Az Ferguson
1 reply · active 756 weeks ago
You should read it, Aths. You may like it. But like I told Staci, if you're not enjoying it after your allotted page rule, there's no reason to torture yourself. I guess I was curious enough to see what happened in the end to keep reading.
Oh I'm sorry to hear you weren't a fan of this one. I got hooked in so quickly, but I can see why it wouldn't be for everyone!
My recent post Review- What They Always Tell Us by Martin Wilson
2 replies · active 756 weeks ago
I'm glad you let me know you got hooked so quickly. That's why I think if someone has the book already or was curious about it, they should read it. I love to hear differing opinions about books and what makes one person love a book and another person hate it. That's interesting to me!
Thank you - I'm the same :) I still post about books I didn't like because I'm sure someone else loved it!
The Gendarme started out slow for me, but I quickly got sucked in by the story. Your review and others I have read disliked the coldness of Emmett. What hit me as I read the reviews is that, sad to admit, Emmett and my boyfriend have very similar personalities, coldish on the outside, yet very emotional inside. I am thinking that is subconsciously made the character more appealing to me than others. Art also lost his first love tragically, so it was like old homeweek for me.
My recent post The Women by TC Boyle Review
1 reply · active 756 weeks ago
That's interesting, Gwen. It makes sense that you had a soft spot for Emmett because of Art's loss. I love how people's life experiences affect their reading. I think we've talked about that before.

Post a new comment

Comments by

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails